Download Ebook Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, by Robert B. Edgerton
As known, book Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton is popular as the window to open up the world, the life, and also extra thing. This is exactly what the people now require so much. Even there are lots of people which don't such as reading; it can be an option as referral. When you actually need the means to create the following inspirations, book Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton will actually lead you to the way. Moreover this Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton, you will certainly have no regret to get it.
Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, by Robert B. Edgerton
Download Ebook Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, by Robert B. Edgerton
Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton When writing can alter your life, when writing can enhance you by supplying much cash, why do not you try it? Are you still quite baffled of where understanding? Do you still have no suggestion with just what you are visiting create? Currently, you will require reading Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton A great writer is a good viewers simultaneously. You can define how you create depending on exactly what publications to read. This Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton can assist you to solve the problem. It can be among the right resources to develop your writing skill.
As we stated in the past, the modern technology assists us to constantly realize that life will certainly be constantly less complicated. Checking out publication Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton practice is also among the benefits to obtain today. Why? Technology can be utilized to supply guide Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton in only soft documents system that can be opened each time you really want as well as almost everywhere you require without bringing this Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton prints in your hand.
Those are some of the advantages to take when obtaining this Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton by online. However, exactly how is the method to get the soft documents? It's quite right for you to visit this page considering that you could obtain the web link page to download and install the e-book Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton Just click the web link offered in this short article and goes downloading. It will not take significantly time to obtain this e-book Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton, like when you should go for e-book store.
This is also among the factors by obtaining the soft file of this Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton by online. You could not need even more times to invest to go to guide shop and also look for them. Often, you additionally don't discover guide Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton that you are looking for. It will lose the moment. However right here, when you see this web page, it will be so simple to obtain and download guide Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton It will certainly not take many times as we mention previously. You can do it while doing something else in your home and even in your office. So simple! So, are you doubt? Merely exercise exactly what we provide here and also check out Sick Societies: Challenging The Myth Of Primitive Harmony, By Robert B. Edgerton exactly what you enjoy to read!
Edgerton challenges the notion that primitive societies were happy and healthy before they were corrupted and oppressed by colonialism. He surveys a range of ethnographic writings, and shows that many of these so-called innocent societies were cruel, confused and misled.
- Sales Rank: #301939 in Books
- Published on: 1992-11-02
- Released on: 1992-11-02
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.25" h x 1.10" w x 6.12" l, 1.22 pounds
- Binding: Hardcover
- 288 pages
- ISBN13: 9780029089255
- Condition: New
- Notes: BRAND NEW FROM PUBLISHER! 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. Tracking provided on most orders. Buy with Confidence! Millions of books sold!
About the Author
Robert Edgerton, PhD, is Professor Emeritus of the department of anthropology at the University of California Los Angeles and the author of several books, including Like Lions They Fought, Sick Societies, and Warriors of the Rising Sun.
Most helpful customer reviews
69 of 79 people found the following review helpful.
The case against adaptivism and cultural relativism
By Jean-Francois Virey
In *Sick Societies*, Robert B. Edgerton argues against tworesilient premises of modern anthropology: cultural relativism and adaptivism.
Cultural relativism is the doctrine that there are no universal, objective criteria for evaluating societies, and that cultural beliefs and practices can only be judged from within, relatively to the culture in which they inhere.
Adaptivism is the assumption that whatever long-standing beliefs and cultural practices can be observed in a given society must contribute to the adaptation of the members to their environment, otherwise either the beliefs and practices or the society members themselves would have perished.
Against these two doctrines, Edgerton argues that it is possible objectively to evaluate all existing societies, based on how well they serve human needs and therefore contribute to the longevity, health (both physical and mental) and happiness of their members. Societies are more or less efficient at serving man's life, from the unsurpassed rationality and productivity of modern western societies, to the superstitious, taboo-ridden and dismally poor communities which anthropologists tend to admire.
Examining dozens of examples of so-called "folk" (i.e. small and primitive) societies, Edgerton shows that, contrary to popular belief- and scientific propaganda- they are not necessarily more socially cohesive, peaceful or healthy than the urbanized populations of the West- quite the contrary in fact. More importantly, he demonstrates how the cultural beliefs and practices of the society members themselves are responsible for the evils individuals endure, from depression to sexual mutilation, suicide, starvation, alcoholism, homicide and madness.
*Sick Societies* sometimes reads like a catalogue of cultural maladaptation and expert opinion, and would have benefited from a more rigorous organization of its material, a more transparent outline and a better classification of the phenomena described. Though he rarely errs, Edgerton makes the mistake of package-dealing actual cases of exploitation (involving force or political power) with alleged cases of economic exploitation, implicitly giving credit to Marxist dogma. Some of his statements are also very curious: "Child abuse is often a nonrational behavior" p80; "The exploitation of children... has been... exploitive" p81.
Despite these very minor flaws, the book is a wonderful case for an objective anthropology, which will fill you with amazement and horror at the extremes of human folly and brutality. I was particularly stunned by the description of the 238 state-supported inhabitants of Duddie's Branch, whose degenerate community could have originated in the dystopian visions of an Ayn Rand, although had she invented it, she would have been accused of political caricature and man-hating hysteria.
As companions to this volume, I recommend Keith Windschuttle's *The Killing of History* and Ayn Rand's *Return of the Primitive*. END
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful.
Edgerton puts the myth of 'adaptivism' to bed
By Bradd E. Libby
In the opening and closing chapters, Edgerton makes it clear that he rejects a central tenet of cultural relativism which states that all aspects of a culture are necessarily 'adaptive' and therefore beyond criticism by any other culture's system of beliefs. He then fills the intervening chapters with example after example of practices from every corner of the globe that, if not to the detriment of the health and well-being of many or most members of the culture, are at least without apparent benefit, including: human sacrifice and environmental destruction among native Central and South American tribes, institutionalized gang rape among Papua New Guinean cannibals, sanctioned indolence among Tazmanian men and female genital mutilation in Africa. It would be difficult for a die-hard cultural relativist to explain the 'adaptive' value of say, footbinding, epidemic alcoholism or spousal abuse, which is Edgerton's point exactly. Those who are inclined to reflexively call the author racist should note that even modern American and European cultures, with their widespread belief in astrology and tendency to wildly misestimate certain health and environmental risks, don't escape his focus.
Though the main body is short (a little over 200 pages) and easy to read, the text quickly begins to feel like an extended laundry list, which I suppose makes it an excellent reference for shattering the politically correct myth of social and environmental harmony among non-Western cultures. Even the bibliography, which runs 40 pages, though now a little out of date, is a goldmine.
45 of 52 people found the following review helpful.
full of evidence although sometimes needlessly conciliatory
By A Customer
Edgerton presents cultural research on several "primitive" cultures, detailing their warfare, famine, subjugation of women, suicide, irrational beliefs, poor hygeine, and often depravity. These case-studies end the myth that "all that is primitive is bliss, and all that is industrial is sickness". With this, he demonstrates the fallacies of thinking that each society has acheived its unique balance. He shows the irrationality of cultural and moral relativism. He shows that cultures CAN be judged from the outside, and that all cultural differences ought not to be respected by default.
Proving the adage that "madness is more common in groups than in individuals", Edgerton provides case after case of cultures gone awry.
What position are WE in to evaluate and pass judgement on another culture? If we value freedom, health, productivity, social stability, knowledge, growth, and peace, we are in a good position to criticize the evils and mistakes of any culture.
My only negative criticism of the book is a part in the beginning, in which Edgerton praises relativism for providing us with a much-needed dose of skepticism and wariness. Relativism has indeed made us cautious about passing judgement, but with the categorical refutations Edgerton has collected in disproving the major thrust of relativism, why make concilliations regarding its benefits? Because of his equivocation, I withhold the final star...
Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, by Robert B. Edgerton PDF
Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, by Robert B. Edgerton EPub
Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, by Robert B. Edgerton Doc
Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, by Robert B. Edgerton iBooks
Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, by Robert B. Edgerton rtf
Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, by Robert B. Edgerton Mobipocket
Sick Societies: Challenging the Myth of Primitive Harmony, by Robert B. Edgerton Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar